Manchester United is at a turning point in their search for a distinct playing style and a clear, consistent plan in the fast-paced world of football.
Following a depressing 3-0 loss to Manchester City, it’s clear that Erik ten Hag’s team is a jumble of ideas and lacks the cohesion that supporters want.
Seventeen months into his tenure and three transfer windows later, one would expect to see a more defined identity for Manchester United. Aston Villa, under Unai Emery, has surged to fifth place, showcasing intense, front-foot football.
Down on the south coast, Brighton, managed by Roberto De Zerbi, imitates Pep Guardiola’s Manchester City with dazzling geometric angles in their play, receiving praise for their style.
One might argue that Ten Hag has been given substantial resources, with an investment of £385.4 million, far more than Emery and De Zerbi.
However, the responsibility for shaping the team’s style ultimately lies with the manager, especially at a club with a veto system that ensures no player is forced upon them.
Ten Hag and John Murtough, the football director, have the final say on signings.
Gary Neville blamed the “toxicity” that surrounded the team after United’s defeat by Manchester City, implying that this was the primary cause of the team’s issues.
Because of the Glazers’ handling of the club’s finances and potential sale, supporters are furious and fearful for the team’s future.
Comparing Manchester United to Manchester City, the contrast is stark. City’s leadership, with Khaldoon al-Mubarak, Ferran Soriano, and Txiki Begiristain, is a model of stability and expertise.
Guardiola’s consistent support from the top ensures that the club remains focused on a single direction, even in the face of setbacks.
United fans yearn for such stability but instead witness a constant state of disarray.
If Sir Jim Ratcliffe’s expected purchase of 25% of the club materializes, it may only add to the confusion, potentially endangering the positions of Murtough, Richard Arnold, and Ten Hag.
Ratcliffe appears to view United as a cash cow that falters when it comes to investing in the squad.
The challenge for Ten Hag is that even after a nearly £400 million spending spree on players, the team still lacks a discernible style of play.
Ten Hag’s own words further highlight the inconsistency in his approach. He noted that the players dictate the style of play, but when he had the opportunity to shape his squad with 16 signings, he seemingly didn’t recruit those who could execute the style he prefers.
In conclusion, Manchester United’s quest for a distinctive style of play continues to elude them, leaving fans and pundits alike perplexed.
The blame game has been extended from the owners to the manager and recruitment team, but until a clear vision is established, the team’s direction remains uncertain.