For over a decade, the US men’s national soccer team has aimed high but often fallen short. The trend began with Jürgen Klinsmann in 2011, who promised to transform the team from scrappy underdogs into a world-class squad.
He introduced a revamped youth system and set the expectation that American players would thrive in Europe’s top leagues. However, the progress he promised seemed always just out of reach.
Gregg Berhalter, who took over after Klinsmann, aimed even higher. He vowed to change the world’s view of American soccer by fostering tactical flexibility and fielding the youngest roster in World Cup history.
Yet, like Klinsmann, his bold ambitions didn’t fully materialize. The US team’s recent disappointing exits from the Copa América and the Olympics highlight this gap between promise and performance.
The summer of 2024 was supposed to be a turning point. Instead, the team faltered, leaving fans and experts questioning what has really changed.
In contrast, past US teams, despite being less ambitious, often exceeded expectations with a clear identity and a fighting spirit.
As the US prepares to co-host the 2026 World Cup, the team is at a crossroads. Will it rediscover its roots, or continue chasing an elusive new identity?
